The Garcia family in Nicaragua produces the well-known, robust My Father the Judge Grand Robusto cigar. It gained notoriety after winning Cigar Journal's 2017 Cigar of the Year award and being voted Cigar Aficionado's #1 Cigar of the Year for 2024 with an outstanding 98 rating.

The Judge is renowned for its creamy smoke texture and powerful yet smooth appearance.

First Third: Earthy & Nutty
A "blast" of traditional Garcia family spice kicks off the encounter and quickly calms.
Light soil, cedar, and roasted almonds are the predominant notes.

Undertones: A creamy texture and a faint salinity on the lips.
Crisp white pepper, retrohale.

Second Third: Savoury & Rich
As the ring gauge permits a cool, dense smoke, the flavours become more complex.
Leather, espresso beans, and dark chocolate (cocoa) are the predominant notes.
Undertones: There's a noticeable sweetness that reminds me of molasses or caramel.
Retrohale: A warmer red pepper replaces the white pepper.

Last Third: Vibrant & Strong
This is where the strength reaches its climax, providing a resonant, hefty finish.
Charred wood, wet dirt, and strong black pepper are the main notes.
Toasted bread and a lingering anise (black liquorice) spice are the undertones.
Retrohale: A potent, strong spice that some people may find overpowering.